Guidelines for reviewers

 

The Report of Appreciation of the Article will have the following format and will comprise the following criteria of evaluation of the article:

 

REPORT OF APPRECIATION OF THE ARTICLE SENT FOR PUBLICATION IN THE STUDII JURIDICE JOURNAL

THE TITLE OF THE ARTICLE

 

THE NAME OF THE AUTHOR

In orbi

Evaluation criteria

1. Does the subject of the article correspond to the theme of the Journal?

NO

 

YES

 

2. The objectives of the article are clearly defined

NO

 

YES

 

3. The use of the bibliographic references is correct

NO

 

YES

 

4. The citations used by the author are adequate

NO

 

YES

 

5. The conclusions of the article reflect the object of the article

NO

 

YES

 

6. The logic support of the scientific arguments

NO

 

YES

 

7. The originality of the paper has the following level:

HIGH

 

MEDIUM

 

LOW

 

8. The article contributes to the scientific development

NO

 

YES

 

9. The Abstract of the article corresponds to the demands

NO

 

YES

 

10. Proposal for the publication of the article

Without observations or recommendations

 

With observations

 

With recommendations

 

Does not propose the publication of the article

 

Observations that must be taken into consideration by the author for the publication of the article

 

Recommendations whose inclusion in the text by the author does not impede the publication of the article

 

THE DATE OF SETTING UP THE PRESENT REPORT

 

THE NAME OF THE REVIEWER

In orbi

THE FINAL OPINION OF THE EDITOR OF THE JOURNAL

THE ACCEPTANCE OF THE TEXT

 

THE REFUSAL OF THE TEXT

 

                 

 

The final opinion is being sent to the author along with the Report of Appreciation of the Article sent for publication.

According to the previsions of Law no. 8/1996 concerning copyright and related rights, with the subsequent modifications, the acceptance by the Journal of the materials sent for publication, equates to the valid conclusion of the contract of editing. Under this contract, the author assigns on exclusive basis the reproduction and propagation rights over his work.

The Journal reserves the following rights as regards to the materials accepted for publication:

  • Suggesting the change of their titles, so that they reflect the content and the objectives of the texts;

  • Suggesting rephrasing, styling, correction of some confusing, unclear, incomplete formulations.

    The decision concerning the acceptance for publication or the refusal for publication will be communicated to the author within 45 days of the moment of receiving the article.

    Once sent to the Journal, the materials cannot make the object of an offer to other publications but in case of refusal of their publication.

    We kindly ask our collaborators to respect the law concerning copyright and to avoid any form of plagiarism.

    The Journal does not assume any responsibility in case of plagiarism, this being assumed entirely by the author, both from a legal point of view (civil, contravention, criminal, etc.) and from a deontological point of view.